RatingsGap
2026 · through Week 6

Who did Madden get wrong this week?

We line up every Madden 27 overall rating against what players are actually doing on the field. Green = rated too low. Red = rated too high.

🔥 Week 6 hot takes

— Alex

Most Disrespected rated too low

Production says these players deserve a higher overall. Gap = Madden OVR − the OVR their stats earn. "All" shows up to 2 per position.

  1. 1TBJosiah TrotterLB · 38.5 tackles · 3 TFL · 1 sacks · 1 INT−22OVR 75 · should be 97
  2. 2NYGDeonte BanksCB · 1 INT · 8 PD · 14.5 tackles · 0 FF−21OVR 78 · should be 99
  3. 3TBJacob ParrishCB · 1 INT · 9 PD · 25.5 tackles · 0 FF−20OVR 79 · should be 99
  4. 4DETD.J. WonnumEDGE · 5 sacks · 7 QB hits · 4 TFL · 0 FF−20OVR 76 · should be 96
  5. 5DETDerrick BarnesLB · 22 tackles · 4 TFL · 3 sacks · 1 INT−19OVR 75 · should be 94
  6. 6CARBryce YoungQB · 1,549 pass yds · 11 TD · 2 INT · 25 rush yds−18OVR 80 · should be 98
  7. 7HOUC.J. StroudQB · 1,714 pass yds · 9 TD · 1 INT · 76 rush yds−18OVR 79 · should be 97
  8. 8CLEMason GrahamDT · 4 sacks · 5 QB hits · 6 TFL · 0 FF−18OVR 81 · should be 99
  9. 9GBEvan WilliamsS · 1 INT · 4 PD · 35.5 tackles · 0 FF−18OVR 80 · should be 98
  10. 10CINJordan BattleS · 3 INT · 4 PD · 26.5 tackles · 0 FF−18OVR 78 · should be 96

Most Overrated rated too high

Big ratings, smaller production (so far). Injuries and tiny samples can cause this. That's part of the debate.

  1. 1DENPat Surtain IICB · 0 INT · 1 PD · 16.5 tackles · 0 FF+29OVR 97 · should be 68
  2. 2TBVita VeaDT · 0 sacks · 3 QB hits · 0 TFL · 0 FF+26OVR 94 · should be 68
  3. 3NYGBrian BurnsEDGE · 0 sacks · 2 QB hits · 0 TFL · 0 FF+25OVR 89 · should be 64
  4. 4CARDerrick BrownDT · 0 sacks · 3 QB hits · 0 TFL · 0 FF+23OVR 96 · should be 73
  5. 5PHISaquon BarkleyRB · 182 rush yds · 8 rec yds · 0 TD+21OVR 91 · should be 70
  6. 6DENCourtland SuttonWR · 13 rec · 123 yds · 1 TD · 28 targets+20OVR 86 · should be 66
  7. 7CARMike JacksonCB · 0 INT · 0 PD · 5 tackles · 0 FF+19OVR 81 · should be 62
  8. 8ATLJessie BatesS · 0 INT · 2 PD · 23.5 tackles · 1 FF+18OVR 94 · should be 76
  9. 9LACJustin HerbertQB · 1,141 pass yds · 5 TD · 8 INT · 168 rush yds+18OVR 83 · should be 65
  10. 10CLEJared VerseEDGE · 0 sacks · 5 QB hits · 4 TFL · 0 FF+17OVR 88 · should be 71
Search all 555 rated players →

Biggest rating changes this week

Risers ▲

Fallers ▼

Madden 27 Week 5 roster update · OVR changes for players we track · Source: maddenratings.com · checked Oct 18, 2026

Gear for the grind

Controller pickThe pad we'd actually use for Madden. Link coming soon.
Headset pickHear the snap count. Link coming soon.
Game deal pickBest price we can find on the game. Link coming soon.

Heads up: some links here may become affiliate links, which means this site could earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Gaming gear only. Never betting.

Get the gap in your inbox

The RatingsGap weekly email

One short email a week: the most disrespected and most overrated players, the biggest Madden rating moves, and Alex's hot takes. Free. You must be 13 or older to sign up.

We only ask for your email. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.

Tracking 440 rated players with enough snaps through Week 6. Stats: nflverse (CC-BY 4.0). How the gap works.